Just jumped off of the phone with Lifeproof. Posting photos so they can see charge port door and foam insert.
I’m not sure which way the foam goes back in. In my mind, the oval depression would line up with the oval port opening of the case, but the lip that goes under the hinge is now forced under.
And that, then, leads to the answer, I think. I believe that this works when the seal is placed OVER the hinge- not under.
Sorry for the trouble, Cassie (Lifeproof Rep). I’ll test this, again, with the seal resting on the hinge.
For those who are interested (me), the reason this whole question came about, was because I was trying to thouroughly dry the case. So I shook the case to get the thin, yellow gasket that lines the perimiter of the case out. It came out, but so did the port seal. Just didn’t know how it went back in.